CVE-2019-17059

Catalpa 网络安全爱好者
  2021-12-14 2021-12-14 Created   2024-10-17 08:46:20 2024-10-17 08:46:20 Updated   4.2k Words  22 Mins  

2019 年 10 月 1 日，CVE 官方发布了编号为 CVE-2019-17059 的漏洞：Cyberoam 防火墙任意代码执行。本文对此漏洞进行分析。

漏洞的发现者在 2019 年 10 月 7 日左右发布了关于此漏洞的具体信息 ，但文章中隐藏了很多关键细节。

A. 数据处理流程

Cyberoam 底层使用一个修改过的 Linux 系统，整体框架设计比较复杂，包含一个 JAVA 编写的前端服务，以及 Embedded perl 编写的后端服务，前后端通过一种自定义的类 HTTP 格式数据进行通信。

A.1 前端

netstat 查看端口监听情况，发现监听 80 端口的服务启动命令为

1
apache -d /_conf/httpd

来到 /_conf/httpd/conf 目录下可以找到 apache 相关配置文件 httpd.conf，其内部会引用子文件：

1
Include /cfs/web/apache/httpd.conf

/cfs/web/apache/httpd.conf，内容如下

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
Listen 80
<VirtualHost *:80>
ServerName manage.cyberoam
<Proxy *>
AddDefaultCharset utf-8
</Proxy>
RewriteEngine On
RewriteRule	/WEB-INF/* - [F]
RewriteRule	/properties/* - [F]
RewriteRule ^/$ /corporate/webpages/login.jsp [R=302]
ErrorDocument 500 /error/INTERNAL_SERVER_ERROR.html
ErrorDocument 503 /error/APP_SERVER_NOT_AVAILABLE.html
ErrorDocument 404 /error/FILE_NOT_EXISTS.html
ProxyPass /corporate/images !
ProxyPass /corporate/dg !
ProxyPass /corporate/APIController !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/images !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/css !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/javascript !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/FusionCharts !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/graycss !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/grayimages !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/defaultcss !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/defaultimages !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/lite1css !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/lite1images !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/lite2css !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/lite2images !
ProxyPass /corporate/iview/jqplot !
ProxyPass /corporate http://localhost:8009/corporate
ProxyPassReverse /corporate http://localhost:8009/corporate
ProxyPass /corporate/iview http://localhost:8009/corporate/iview
ProxyPassReverse /corporate/iview http://localhost:8009/corporate/iview
RewriteRule ^/portal(/)?$ - [F]
RewriteRule /corporate/webpages/tportal/* - [F]
ProxyPass /registrationserver http://cyberoamupdate.cyberoam.com/demoregserver/servlet/CyberoamSyncManager retry=0
ProxyPassReverse /registrationserver http://cyberoamupdate.cyberoam.com/demoregserver/servlet/CyberoamSyncManager
ProxyPass /notificationmsg http://cyberoamregistration.cyberoam.com/datetime/notificationmsg.jsp retry=0
ProxyPassReverse /notificationmsg http://cyberoamregistration.cyberoam.com/datetime/notificationmsg.jsp
ProxyPreserveHost On
RewriteEngine   On
Rewritecond  %{request_method} !^(GET|POST)$
RewriteRule .* - [F]
ExpiresActive On
ExpiresDefault "access plus 1 month"
AddOutputFilterByType DEFLATE text/plain
AddOutputFilterByType DEFLATE text/html
AddOutputFilterByType DEFLATE text/css
AddOutputFilterByType DEFLATE application/javascript
AddOutputFilterByType DEFLATE application/x-javascript
</VirtualHost>

这里看到监听外部 80 端口的服务配置，当用户访问 /corporate 接口时，请求会被转发到 http://localhost:8009/corporate，tomcat 监听此接口，启动命令：

1
tomcat -X mx64M -X ms12M -X ss128k -X asyncgc -X noinlining -X replication:none -X compactalways -D java.io.tmpdir=/tmp-Djava.awt.headless=true -D jetty.class.path=/bin/jetty/lib/javax.servlet.jar:/bin/jetty/lib/org.mortbay.jetty.jar:/bin/jetty/webapps/corporate/properties:/bin/jetty/webapps/corporate/jar/jta26.jar:/bin/jetty/webapps/reports/properties -X bootclasspath:/bin/jamvm/share/jamvm/classes:/bin/classpath/share/classpath -D STOP.PORT=-1 -jar /bin/jetty/start.jar /bin/jetty/etc/jetty.xml

jetty.xml 部分配置

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
<?xml version="1.0"?> 
<!DOCTYPE Configure PUBLIC "-//Mort Bay Consulting//DTD Configure//EN" "http:/>

<!-- =============================================================== -->
<!-- Configure the Jetty Server                                      -->
<!-- =============================================================== -->
<Configure class="org.mortbay.jetty.Server">

  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <!-- Increase Maximum Form Content Size                              -->
  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <Call class="java.lang.System" name="setProperty">
      <Arg>org.mortbay.http.HttpRequest.maxFormContentSize</Arg>
      <Arg>4194304</Arg>
  </Call>
  
  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <!-- Configure the Request Listeners                                 -->
  <!-- =============================================================== -->

  <!-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -->
  <!-- Add and configure a HTTP listener to port 8080                       -->
  <!-- The default port can be changed using: java -Djetty.port=80     -->
  <!-- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -->
  <Call name="addListener">
    <Arg>
      <New class="org.mortbay.http.SocketListener">
        <Set name="Port"><SystemProperty name="jetty.port" default="8009"/></S>
		<Set name="PoolName">P1</Set>
        <Set name="MinThreads">20</Set>
        <Set name="MaxThreads">200</Set>
        <Set name="lowResources">50</Set>
        <Set name="MaxIdleTimeMs">30000</Set>
        <Set name="LowResourcePersistTimeMs">2000</Set>
        <Set name="acceptQueueSize">0</Set>
        <Set name="ConfidentialPort">8443</Set>
        <Set name="IntegralPort">8443</Set>
      </New>
    </Arg>
  </Call>

  <Set name="WebApplicationConfigurationClassNames">
    <Array type="java.lang.String">
      <Item>org.mortbay.jetty.servlet.XMLConfiguration</Item>
      <Item>org.mortbay.jetty.servlet.JettyWebConfiguration</Item>

      <!--
      <Item>org.mortbay.jetty.servlet.TagLibConfiguration</Item>
      <Item>org.mortbay.jetty.servlet.jsr77.Configuration</Item>
      -->
    </Array>
  </Set>

  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <!-- Configure the Contexts                                          -->
  <!-- =============================================================== -->

  <Set name="rootWebApp">root</Set>
  
  <Call name="addWebApplications">
    <Arg></Arg>
    <Arg><SystemProperty name="jetty.home" default="."/>/webapps/</Arg>
    <Arg><SystemProperty name="jetty.home" default="."/>/etc/webdefault.xml</A>
    <Arg type="boolean">true</Arg><!--extract WARs-->
    <Arg type="boolean">false</Arg><!-- java 2 compliant class loader -->
  </Call>

  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <!-- Configure the Request Log                                       -->
  <!-- =============================================================== -->
  <Set name="RequestLog">
    <New class="org.mortbay.http.NCSARequestLog">
	<Arg><SystemProperty name="logs" default="/" />/log/tomcat.log</Arg>
      <Set name="retainDays">0</Set>
      <Set name="append">true</Set>
      <Set name="extended">false</Set>
      <Set name="buffered">false</Set>
      <Set name="LogTimeZone">GMT</Set>
    </New>
  </Set>

</Configure>

这里找到 web 目录在 /bin/jetty/webapps/corporate/ 下，web.xml 部分配置

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
<servlet-mapping>                                   
    <servlet-name>Controller</servlet-name>
    <url-pattern>/Controller</url-pattern>
</servlet-mapping>
<servlet-mapping>                                                                                                                             
    <servlet-name>APIController</servlet-name>                                                                                            
    <url-pattern>/APIController</url-pattern>                                                                                             
</servlet-mapping>   
<servlet-mapping>                                   
    <servlet-name>Controller</servlet-name>
    <url-pattern>/sslvpnuserportal/manager/CRSSLAuthenticationManager</url-pattern>
</servlet-mapping>
<servlet-mapping>                                   
    <servlet-name>RefreshServlet</servlet-name>
    <url-pattern>/corporate/servlet/RefreshServlet</url-pattern>
</servlet-mapping>
<servlet-mapping>                                   
    <servlet-name>TelnetServlet</servlet-name>
    <url-pattern>/corporate/servlet/TelnetServlet</url-pattern>
</servlet-mapping>

从配置中可以看到前端有几个可访问的接口，其中 /Controller 比较关键，它对应的类定义如下

1
2
3
4
5
<servlet>
    <servlet-name>Controller</servlet-name>
    <servlet-class>cyberoam.corporate.servlets.CyberoamCommonServlet</servlet-class>
    <load-on-startup>1</load-on-startup>
</servlet>

反编译这个类，部分代码：

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
// ...
try {
    int1 = Integer.parseInt(httpServletRequest2.getParameter("mode"));
}
catch (Exception ex2) {
    int1 = -447;
}
// ...
if (!eventByMode.getOPCode().equals("login") && !eventByMode.getOPCode().equals("iview_login") && eventByMode.getMode() != 500 && eventByMode.getMode() != 172 && eventByMode.getMode() != 404 && eventByMode.getMode() != 34 && eventByMode.getMode() != 405 && !eventByMode.getOPCode().equals("login_report") && eventByMode.getMode() != 451 && eventByMode.getMode() != 458 && !eventByMode.getOPCode().equals("ccc_login") && eventByMode.getMode() != 603 && eventByMode.getMode() != 746 && eventByMode.getMode() != 958 && eventByMode.getMode() != 605 && eventByMode.getMode() != 531) {
    if (eventByMode.getMode() != 720 && CheckSession.isAdminSessionLock(httpServletRequest2)) {
        httpServletResponse.getWriter().print("{\"status\":597,message:\"Session is Lock\"}");
        CyberoamLogger.debug("CSC", "Lock Response is: 597");
        return;
    }
    if (CheckSession.isSessionExpire(httpServletRequest2)) {
        httpServletResponse.sendRedirect(String.valueOf(httpServletRequest2.getContextPath()) + "/webpages/SessionExpired.jsp");
        return;
    }
}
// ...
if (eventByMode.getRequesttype() == 1) {
    transactionBean.setTransactionID(CSCClient.getTransactionID());
    CyberoamAjaxHelper.process(httpServletRequest2, httpServletResponse, eventByMode, transactionBean, sqlReader);
}
else if (eventByMode.getRequesttype() == 2) {
    transactionBean.setTransactionID(CSCClient.getTransactionID());
    CyberoamCustomHelper.process(httpServletRequest2, httpServletResponse, eventByMode, transactionBean, sqlReader);
}

这段代码从用户请求中获取 mode 参数的值，然后进行数个判断，除特定的一些值以外，都需要进行 session 验证。

如果通过验证，则调用 CyberoamCustomHelper.process 函数，此函数逻辑复杂，简单来讲，它会进一步解析用户提交的请求，根据 mode 值的不同进行不同的处理，以无需身份验证的 458 功能为例，它会调用函数 QuarantineDownloadUtility.handleReleaseRequestFromMail，部分代码：

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
HashMap<Object, Object> hashMap = new HashMap<Object, Object>();
// ...
hashMap.put("release", paramHttpServletRequest.getParameter("release"));
// ...
hashMap.put("___username", str2);
hashMap.put("currentlyloggedinuserip", paramHttpServletRequest.getHeader("X-FORWARDED-FOR"));
// ...
CyberoamLogger.debug("Spam Mail", "Calling opcode --> " + eventBean.getOPCode());
i = cSCClient.sendWizardEvent(eventBean, hashMap, paramSqlReader);
// ...

之后会调用 cSCClient.sendWizardEvent

1
2
3
// ...
i = send(paramEventBean, jSONObject, paramHttpServletRequest, paramSqlReader);
// ...

这里来到关键位置，send 函数内部会构造出之前提到的类 HTTP 格式数据，并转发到 127.0.0.1 299 端口。

A.2 后端

查看端口开放信息，找到监听 299 的服务是 csc 二进制文件，启动命令为

1
csc -L 3 -c /_conf/csc/csc.conf

在 /_conf/csc/ 目录下可以找到很多 .conf 文件，每个文件中都是一种类似 perl 的伪代码，通过 IDA 反编译分析 csc 发现程序引用了大量 perl 相关函数

经调查 csc 可能修改了原始 perl，自己实现了一套新的 perl 解释器，并在其上添加了格式解析相关逻辑。

前端所有功能发送到后端之后，都会先调用 apiInterface 接口，此接口在 perl 层面实现了鉴权、参数过滤、请求分发等操作。

我们可以利用 tcpdump 截获前后端之间的通信流量

1
tcpdump -i lo -A port 299

样例请求和响应

1
2
3
4
5
opcode getCustomerInfo csc/1.2
content-type:json
content-length:118

{"APIVersion":"063.051","___component":"LOCAL","___username":"LOCAL","mode":370,"currentlyloggedinuserip":"127.0.0.1"}
1
2
3
4
csc/1.2 200 OK
content-length:74

NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL###NULL

以这个请求为例，在 csc 目录下搜索字符串 getCustomerInfo 可以找到此功能的定义

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
OPCODE getCustomerInfo {
	<code>
		$modulename=$request->{modulename};
		$custinfo="fail";
	</code>	
	custinfo=DLOPEN(do_nvram_get,customer.info)		

	ON_FAIL{
		LOG applog "getCustomerInfo opcode failed\n"
		REPLY text "fail" 500
	}
	REPLY text $custinfo 200
}

其余功能的调用类似，都是以类 HTTP 形式发送到 299 端口，然后 csc 找到对应 perl 函数进行调用。

A.3 mode 定义

代码中有很多 mode，每个 mode 对应 perl 中的不同函数，具体定义可以在 java Modes.class 中找到，部分定义如下

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
public static final int ACCESS_TIME_POLICY_ADD = 1;

public static final int ACCESS_TIME_POLICY_EDIT = 2;

public static final int SURFING_QUOTA_POLICY_ADD = 3;

public static final int SURFING_QUOTA_POLICY_EDIT = 4;

public static final int NAT_POLICY_ADD = 5;

public static final int NAT_POLICY_EDIT = 6;

public static final int DATA_TRANSFER_POLICY_ADD = 7;

public static final int DATA_TRANSFER_POLICY_EDIT = 8;

public static final int ACCESS_TIME_POLICY_DELETE = 10;

public static final int UNICAST_ROUTE_ADD = 11;

public static final int UNICAST_ROUTE_EDIT = 12;

public static final int UNICAST_ROUTE_DELETE = 13;

public static final int MULTICAST_ROUTE_ADD = 14;

public static final int MULTICAST_ROUTE_EDIT = 15;

public static final int MULTICAST_ROUTE_DELETE = 16;

B. 漏洞分析

根据披露信息，存在漏洞的功能 mode = 458，在 mode 定义中找到功能名称叫做 RELEASE_QUARANTINE_MAIL_FROM_MAIL，同时在 CyberoamCommonServlet 类中可以看到这个功能无需身份验证即可访问。

前端中对此功能处理逻辑

  1. CyberoamCustomHelper
1
2
3
if (eventBean.getMode() == 458) {
    new QuarantineDownloadUtility().handleReleaseRequestFromMail(httpServletRequest, httpServletResponse, sqlReader);
}
  1. QuarantineDownloadUtility
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
public void handleReleaseRequestFromMail(HttpServletRequest paramHttpServletRequest, HttpServletResponse paramHttpServletResponse, SqlReader paramSqlReader) {
    int i = 1;
    String str = null;
    JSONObject jSONObject = new JSONObject();
    boolean bool = true;
    try {
        str = paramHttpServletRequest.getParameter("release");
        String str1 = decode(str);
        String[] arrayOfString1 = str1.split("&");
        byte b;
        int j;
        String[] arrayOfString2;
        for (j = (arrayOfString2 = arrayOfString1).length, b = 0; b < j; ) {
            String str2 = arrayOfString2[b];
            String[] arrayOfString = str2.split("=");
            if (arrayOfString.length > 2)
                bool = false; 
            jSONObject.put(arrayOfString[0], (arrayOfString.length > 1) ? arrayOfString[1] : "");
            b++;
        } 
        if ((jSONObject.getString("hdnSender").equals("") || validateEmail(jSONObject.getString("hdnSender"))) && 
            validateEmail(jSONObject.getString("hdnRecipient")) && isSafeFilePath(jSONObject.getString("hdnFilePath")) && 
            bool) {
            paramHttpServletResponse.setContentType("text/html");
            CyberoamLogger.debug("Antivirus/AntiSpam", "CSC Constant value " + CSCConstants.isCCC);
            CSCClient cSCClient = new CSCClient();
            HashMap<Object, Object> hashMap = new HashMap<Object, Object>();
            EventBean eventBean = EventBean.getEventByMode(363);
            hashMap.put("release", paramHttpServletRequest.getParameter("release"));
            if (paramHttpServletRequest != null) {
                String str2;
                arrayOfString2 = null;
                HttpSession httpSession = paramHttpServletRequest.getSession(false);
                if (httpSession != null) {
                    SessionBean sessionBean = (SessionBean)httpSession.getAttribute("sessionbean");
                    if (sessionBean != null) {
                        str2 = sessionBean.getUserName();
                        hashMap.put("___component", CSCConstants.COMPONENT_VALUE);
                    } 
                } 
                if (str2 == null)
                    str2 = "-"; 
                hashMap.put("___username", str2);
                hashMap.put("currentlyloggedinuserip", paramHttpServletRequest.getHeader("X-FORWARDED-FOR"));
            } else {
                hashMap.put("___username", "-");
            } 
            CyberoamLogger.debug("Spam Mail", "Calling opcode --> " + eventBean.getOPCode());
            i = cSCClient.sendWizardEvent(eventBean, hashMap, paramSqlReader);
            CyberoamLogger.debug("Spam Mail", "Status After Call--> " + i);
            if (i == 200) {
                i = 1;
            } else if (i == 547) {
                i = -2;
            } else if (i == 548) {
                i = -3;
            } else {
                i = -1;
            } 
        } else {
            i = -3;
        } 
    } catch (Exception exception) {
        CyberoamLogger.error("Antivirus/AntiSpam", "Exception occured while releaseing mail from Spam Quarantined Digest Mail: " + exception, exception);
        i = -1;
    } 
    CyberoamLogger.debug("Antivirus/AntiSpam", "Mail is released  for mode : " + paramHttpServletRequest.getParameter("mode"));
    try {
        paramHttpServletResponse.setContentType("text/html");
        PrintWriter printWriter = paramHttpServletResponse.getWriter();
        if (i > 0) {
            printWriter.write("<font>The released email will be scanned and delivered.</font>");
        } else if (i == -2) {
            printWriter.write("<font>Email has been released or deleted.</font>");
        } else if (i == -3) {
            printWriter.write("<font>Bad Request.</font>");
        } else {
            printWriter.write("<font>Error while releasing email</font>");
        } 
    } catch (Exception exception) {}
}
  1. cSCClient.sendWizardEvent 发送到 299 端口

QuarantineDownloadUtility 函数中从请求中获取 release 参数，然后对其进行 base64 解码，解码后进行数个参数判断，如果全部通过则执行

1
EventBean eventBean = EventBean.getEventByMode(363);

这里会将 mode 重新设置为 363，从定义中得知 363 对应接口名称为 SEND_MAIL。

从 perl 伪代码中搜索能找到 send_mail 函数，部分代码：

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
opcode send_mail{
    $reason = "";
	$strSubject="";
	</code>
	
	IF("defined $request->{release} and $request->{release} ne '' "){
		<code>$param = $request->{release};</code>
		param = DLOPEN(base64_decode,param)
		LOG applog " Decode values :: $param \n"
		<code>%requestData = split(/[&=]/, $param);
			$mailServerHost = $requestData{hdnDestDomain};
			$mailFrom = $requestData{hdnSender};
			$mailTo   = $requestData{hdnRecipient};
			$file = $QUARANTINE_PATH."/".$requestData{hdnFilePath};
			
			
            $mailfile=$requestData{hdnFilePath};
            $validate_email="false";
            my $email_regex='^([\.]?[_\-\!\#\{\}\$\%\^\&\*\+\=\|\?\'\\\\\\/a-zA-Z0-9])*@([a-zA-Z0-9]([-]?[a-zA-Z0-9]+)*\.)+([a-zA-Z0-9]{0,6})$';
            if($requestData{hdnRecipient} =~ /$email_regex/ && ((defined $requestData{hdnSender} && $requestData{hdnSender} eq '') || $requestData{hdnSender} =~ /$email_regex/) && index($requestData{hdnFilePath},'../') == -1){
                 $validate_email="true";
            }
	</code>
          IF("$validate_email eq 'false'"){
             <code>%response=("status"=>"548","statusmessage"=>"Invalid URL");</code>
             REPLY  %response 500
          }
	}
	ELSE{
		// ...
	}
	// ...
	LOG applog "Values-->\n"
	LOG applog "Mail Server: --> $mailServerHost \n"
	LOG applog "File Path: --> $file \n"
	LOG applog "Mail From: --> $mailFrom \n"
	LOG applog "Mail To: --> $mailTo \n"
	LOG applog "Subject: --> $strSubject \n"
	IF(" -e $file"){
	<code>
		$file = $file .":message/rfc822";
	%mailreq=("mailaction"=>"$MAIL_FORWARD","subject"=>"$strSubject","toEmail"=>"$mailTo","attachmentfile"=>"$file","smtpserverhost"=>"$mailServerHost","fromaddress"=>"$mailFrom");
	</code>
	
        out = OPCODE mail_sender json %mailreq
        // ...
    }
    // ...
}

代码中首先判断 release 参数是否为空，然后对其进行 base64 解码，以 $= 将字符串分割，获取 hdnDestDomain、hdnSender、hdnRecipient、hdnFilePath 四个参数并赋值到不同的变量。

接着利用正则表达式过滤 hdnRecipient 和 hdnSender 参数，验证邮箱格式是否正确，不正确直接返回 500 错误。

如果验证通过，就调用 LOG 打印这些变量的内容，然后利用 -e 判断 $file 即 $QUARANTINE_PATH.”/“.$requestData{hdnFilePath} 文件是否存在，其中 $QUARANTINE_PATH 是一个常量，定义为 /var/quarantine。

如果文件存在，就调用 mail_sender 函数

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
OPCODE mail_sender{
    // ...
    LOG applog "MAIL_SEND: Values-->\n Mail Server: --> $smtpserverhost\n Mail From: --> $fromaddress\n Mail To: --> $toEmail\n Subject: --> $subject\n Username: --> $mailusername\n MailAction:--> $mailaction\n SMTPSecurityMode:--> $smtpsecuritymode\n SMTPCertificate:-->$smtpcertificate\n Appliance IP(LAN):--> $ip\n"
	IF("$mailaction eq $MAIL_WITH_VAR"){
		out = EXEC /bin/cschelper 'mail_send' $fromaddress $fromaddresswithname $toEmail $toEmail $subject "" $smtpserverhost $smtpserverport $mailusername $mailpassword $mailaction $smtpsecuritymode $smtpcertificate $certpassword "1" "$mailbody" "text/html"
	}ELSE IF("$mailaction eq $MAIL_FORWARD"){
		out = EXECSH "/bin/cschelper mail_send '$fromaddress' '$fromaddresswithname' '$toEmail' '$toEmail' '$subject' '$mailbody' '$smtpserverhost' '$smtpserverport' '$mailusername' '$mailpassword' '$mailaction' '$smtpsecuritymode' '$smtpcertificate' '$certpassword' '1' '$attachmentfile'"
	}ELSE IF("$mailaction eq $MAIL_ATTACHMENT"){
		out = EXECSH "/bin/cschelper mail_send '$fromaddress' '$fromaddresswithname' '$toEmail' '$toEmail' '$subject' '$mailbody' '$smtpserverhost' '$smtpserverport' '$mailusername' '$mailpassword' '$mailaction' '$smtpsecuritymode' '$smtpcertificate' '$certpassword' '1' '$attachmentfile'"
	}
	// ...
}

此函数头部进行很多初始化操作，随后根据 $mailaction 值的不同执行不同逻辑，在 send_mail 函数中可以看到 传入的 $mailaction 值应该是 $MAIL_FORWARD，那么这里会执行

1
out = EXECSH "/bin/cschelper mail_send '$fromaddress' '$fromaddresswithname' '$toEmail' '$toEmail' '$subject' '$mailbody' '$smtpserverhost' '$smtpserverport' '$mailusername' '$mailpassword' '$mailaction' '$smtpsecuritymode' '$smtpcertificate' '$certpassword' '1' '$attachmentfile'"

EXECSH 对应的操作是 /bin/sh -c，同时这条命令中拼接了我们可控的 $smtpserverhost，存在命令注入漏洞。

C. 漏洞触发

在触发漏洞的路径上还存在几个问题

C.1 绕过文件判断

在调用 mail_sender 函数之前存在一个对 $file 是否存在的判断，其中 $file 参数是 $QUARANTINE_PATH 和用户提交的 hdnFilePath 两个变量拼接而来，也就是说只有$file 存在时，才能触发 mail_sender 功能，$QUARANTINE_PATH 变量的值为 /var/quarantine，而通常情况下攻击者无法得知此目录下有哪些文件。

为了绕过这个判断，我们可以提交 hdnFilePath=/，拼接后得到 $file = /var/quarantine/，而这里就变成了判断 /var/quarantine/ 目录是否存在，显然可以通过。

C.2 命令注入

在注入命令的时候，相关代码如下

1
2
3
ELSE IF("$mailaction eq $MAIL_FORWARD"){
		out = EXECSH "/bin/cschelper mail_send '$fromaddress' '$fromaddresswithname' '$toEmail' '$toEmail' '$subject' '$mailbody' '$smtpserverhost' '$smtpserverport' '$mailusername' '$mailpassword' '$mailaction' '$smtpsecuritymode' '$smtpcertificate' '$certpassword' '1' '$attachmentfile'"
	}

其中 $smtpserverport 变量是用户可控的 hdnDestDomain，但单纯使用反引号或者分号不能执行命令，需要先使用单引号将待注入的命令闭合才可以。

C.3 日志调试

perl 部分没有很好的方法可以调试，但在代码中存在很多 LOG 打印日志信息，我们可以在 /var/tslog/applog.log 文件中找到这些信息，通过调试信息辅助分析。

C.4 漏洞触发演示

asciicast

  • Title: CVE-2019-17059
  • Author: Catalpa
  • Created at : 2021-12-14 00:00:00
  • Updated at : 2024-10-17 08:46:20
  • Link: https://wzt.ac.cn/2021/12/14/CVE-2019-17059/
  • License: This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.
On this page
CVE-2019-17059
  1. A. 数据处理流程
    1. A.1 前端
    2. A.2 后端
    3. A.3 mode 定义
  2. B. 漏洞分析
  3. C. 漏洞触发
    1. C.1 绕过文件判断
    2. C.2 命令注入
    3. C.3 日志调试
    4. C.4 漏洞触发演示